September 17, 2025

What Are 5 Things in Your Kitchen You’d Never Be Caught Without?

ayo edebiri

What do you always have in your kitchen? When Nora Ephron wrote her famous list of things she’d miss and not miss, she said she’d miss butter, pie, bacon, waffles, and the concept of waffles. And it made me wonder what foods bring other people joy.

Curious, I texted cookbook author Dan Pelosi this morning, and his list was: “olive oil, rigatoni, castelvetrano olives, lemons, anchovies.” And our beloved Jenny Rosenstrach told me: “hummus, yogurt, cabbage, cottage cheese — and this time of year, Mallomars.”

Eric Kim and Adam Roberts

Eric Kim and Adam Roberts

Then I asked my friend Adam of The Amateur Gourmet, and he said: “blueberries, bittersweet chocolate, Frantoia olive oil, anchovies, and Aleppo pepper for that fruity heat.”

Kate Baer, poet and mom of four, has “tortilla chips, feta, roadside fruit, frozen peas, and sourdough bread from my sister in law.”

Ali Slagle just wrote about Samin Nosrat’s 40 essential ingredients, which include Dijon mustard, chickpeas, basmati rice, bone-in chicken thighs, and red onions. And from Trader Joe’s? She stocks Taiwanese Green Onion Pancakes in the freezer. “Then I can — for breakfast or dinner — have a scrambled egg or two on a scallion pancake.”

Finally, I had to ask Freddie, my personal chef, and his list was: “apples, eggs, chicken stock, olive oil, and black pepper (in the mill, you have to grate it on the spot). Oh, and broccoli in the freezer, so I can sauté it with garlic and oil for my boys.”

anton

What five things do you always have on hand? I’d love to hear. Our own list has stayed mostly the same: cheddar cheese, French yogurts, honeycrisp apples, Gotham Greens pesto, and cavatappi pasta. Plus, all the boxes of Cheerios for teenage boy breakfasts!

P.S. My favorite lunch, the best jarred tomato sauce, and what are your pet peeves? (I have a weird one.) Also, we asked this question three years ago and nine years ago! Have your answers changed?

PREVIOUS ARTICLE

NEXT ARTICLE

Comments

73 comments
N.J.

– Quality olive oil, bought straight from the farmer – but does this one count? – Fresh tomatoes (big ones and cherry) and at least one seasonal fruit – As many pickled things as possible (kimchi, dill pickles, silver onions) – At least 3 types of loose leaf tea – Long grain rice and split yellow mung beans

Katt

Potatoes, greek yogurt, eggs, dark chocolate, frozen broccoli

Violet

Samal oelek chili paste, greek yogurt, canned tuna, cabbage, and soy milk.

Courtney

Eggs, butter, parm, broccoli, goldfish. So many goldfish.

kiki

maldon, balsamic, apples, coffee, dijon (runners up include almond butter and truffles)

BLE

I love these lists! -hard cheese -whole wheat bread -leafy greens -dijon mustard -dark chocolate

N.K.

– pasture raised eggs – avocados – bananas – oat milk – organic coffee

Carrol Duke

Pet peeve: cut open an avocado to find brown mush inside

Lisa

Cheeses Olives and pickles Fresh fruit and vegetables for snacking Luzianne tea bags Chocolate Chicken thighs Seriously, this is what I eat pretty much every day.

Ingrid Emery

Pumpkin seeds, tahini, cider vinegar, dried lentils, olives

Erae

Food: Sliced Bread, Cheddar Cheese, Greek Yogurt, Smoked Turkey & Dark Roast Coffee. Essentials: Cutco Scissors, Paring Knife, Cutting Board, Dish Towel, Napkins.

Bea

Apart from the staples (pasta, rice, evoo, coffee etc) I tend to always have lemons, almonds, good quality olives, parmesan cheese and tinned beans of many kinds.

Sonya

Kicking Horse coffee Irish tea Bakery-made grain and seed bread Hot sauce I make myself Local honey

allie

Miso (white Miso Master or any Shared Cultures), kosher salt, butter/olive oil, peas, oat/almond milk

Rachel

Olive oil, eggs, parmigiano reggiano, onions, chickpeas

Jen

Olive oil, avocado, eggs, chick peas, sugar snap peas. (I don’t think salt and pepper should count!)

Dana

Carrots, celery, onions, canned tomatoes, sour cream

Betsy Lewis-Moreno

Garlic, onions, yogurt, chiles, cheese

Kat

Would love to know Eric Kim’s list! He’s such a good writer and I’ve loved the recipes he’s published.

Sophie

Olive oil and maldon sea salt are such basic essentials in my kitchen I feel like I should get those two for free. I always also have garlic, lemons, canned chickpeas, tomatoes and parmesan.

Kelly

Galena Garlic espresso balsamic, butter or olive oil, Aldi Specially Selected Maryland Crabcakes, Aldi Season’s Choice frozen broccoli, Himalayan Pink Salt

Sara

There are definitely a whole bunch of kitchen staples like good olive oil and salt that I struggle to do without. And then there those things that just make a kitchen feel like home. You know, the things that you miss when you’re staying at an Airbnb or another house, even when all of the staples are there. For me, those 5 things are: – Cultured butter – Eggs – Coffee beans – Rice – Cheese. Any cheese.

Daniela

Dark chocolate Butter Pasta Olive oil Milk

Anne

1.) Rancho Gordo beans of any variety 2.) Diamond Kosher salt 3.) Real olive oil (Start reading the labels. Shocking!) 4.)Fresh cilantro 5.) Fresh limes

Courtney

Greek Yogurt Coffee Half and Half Frozen Fruit (smoothies!) Olive Oil and (bonus: Whole wheat bread)

Sophie

Creamy PB Bread Eggs Beer Chocolate I often think I have the fridge of a 22 yr old boy and not a vegetarian 40 something

Tiffani

Coffee/Oatly barista blend oatmilk/local honey Blocks of parm and sharp cheddar Olive oil and butter Whole milk plain Greek yogurt Garlic and yellow onions

SDY

Parmesan Pasta Lemons Garlic Yogurt and many more!

Catherine

Chili and garlic oil, coffee, soy milk, bread and cheese.

Alex

Olive oil, garlic, lemon (classic Lebanese trio) Eggs Sea salt and fresh cracked peppe Sourdough and/or Rye bread with salted butter

Consuella

me, the baker in the house: fresh oatmeal bread homemade strawberry jam salted butter earl grey and, uh, chocolate chip cookies? my partner, the cook in the house: olive oil green veggies salt chili crisp penzey’s bavarian spice mix

Maria Anagnostopoulou

olive oil greek yogurt eggs grated cheese tomatoes lentils

Jenni

Dark chocolate Honey crisp apples Power greens (for smoothies) Almond butter Good olive oil

Eastcoast Canuck

ingredients: – evoo and butter (team both) – maple syrup (obligatory!) – salad greens – eggs – garlic work horse tools: – salad spinner – mortar and pestle – sharp knives – rasp – tongs

Courtney

love the work horse tools addition – so key!! mine are: french press coffee grinder blender sharp knives tongs

Dawn

Dark chocolate Peanut butter Sourdough bread Eggs Coffee

DebPS

My wee shoulder angel says olive oil, tomatoes, Parmesan, sourdough bread, and avocados. The stroppy little devil in my other shoulder says dark chocolate, good potato chips, Diet Coke, red wine, and shortbread ❤️

Caitlin

Love it haha

Debbie P

Tofu, nonfat plain Greek yogurt, bananas, chickpeas, almond milk.

Sandra

Moroccan Tea Tagine Couscous Bastille Tandis Zaalouk

jussash

Dish Soap Liquid Garlic Dish Soap Decent brand of Soy and Sesame Oil (which can transform even plain ol’ Sashimi with creativity Olive Oil assuming you have any ingredients to cook) Black Pepper and Curry Powder (totally different powder for fish and meats) Fresh Garlic and Fresh Thai Red Chilli Peppers (which can even ooomph up any insipid Pasta) Curry Powder (and it’s different for Meat and Fish Curries, in where I was raised)

HollyB.

My cooking and grocery lists change with the seasons, but weekly staples are whole milk, Greek whole-milk yoghurt, tinned beans (chickpeas, cannellini, kidney), deli sandwich fixings for my boys, and 00 and bread flour. I’m so excited to be moving into cool-weather cooking, my absolute favourite!

Kristen

Coffee, chocolate chips, bananas, milk, almond butter

Angela

Black pepper (put in nearly everything) Chicken stock Eggs Butter Rice Garlic Sesame oil Soy sauce

Char

Oooh, fun! For ingredients: Diamond Crystal kosher salt (I literally cannot function in a kitchen without it), organic salted butter, my husband’s homemade sourdough, apples (Honeycrisp or Ambrosia), eggs For kitchen tools: My 8” chefs knife, microplane rasp, a good stainless steel pan, my dutch oven, and the digital scale.

Lindsey

Wow nailed it! Retweet these answers.

Nickey

Apples, lactose free half and half, salmon, romaine lettuce, coffee

wednesday

PG Tips Milk Sugar Bananas Avocados

Sasa

Rice, eggs, shoyu, cabbage, oil.

Isabella

Wait, can I go again??! Because I also cannot function without: Coffee Eggs Pasta Bread ALL OF THE PRODUCE

Colleen S

Cottage cheese, fresh Parmesan, pasta, salmon (canned or frozen), and some kind of crunchy snack.

Isabella

Olive oil, onions, celery, batches of dreamy cooked beans in the freezer, parmesan!

Mariah

As a non-cook my 5 tings – yogurt, tahini, blueberries, my homemade sour dough, avocados My husband – the cook – onions, garlic, salt, butter olive oil. the list doesn’t include the proteins and veggies we live on.

Martha

Olive oil, butter, sliced bread…either sourdough or Daves Killer 21 grain , canned beans, half and half and coffee beans!

Elly Harris

Bread, butter, jam, tea, cheese. And biscuits.

Alyssa

What is so fun is I really thought this was going to be a list of 5 kitchen TOOLS you couldn’t live without. My answer would be: my ravioli shaped spoon rest that delights me every single day, my bench scraper, my salt/pepper cellar, a seasonally appropriate mug, and a Stanley waterbottle. :) But if I have to pick foods: butter, vanilla bean yogurt, Trader Joe’s sweet potato gnocchi, avocado oil, and garlic salt!

Leanne

salt/shoyu pepper oil/butter/olive oil sugar garlic

beth b

Black pepper Coffee Cheese (any kind, thank you, changes weekly) Pasta Butter

Becs

Irish breakfast tea, sourdough bread and butter, french fries, heirloom tomatoes, peaches. And soup — always soup!

Nicole

I almost forgot maple syrup! Canadians, of course

Nicole

olive oil, peanut butter, eggs, gluten-free crackers, cheddar, blueberries, honeycrisp apple, plain greek yogurt, Stoked Oats granola, coffee, cream, gf pasta, Rao’s marinara, parmesan, vidalia onion, lemons, Rooibos tea. I f we are out of one of these it might as well be toilet paper :)

Kate

Love the essential list from Samin – this is a gift to anyone who has ever loved house and has had to restock a kitchen! Coffee, cream, eggs, flour, broccoli. If we are out of these, I’m going to the store.

Sara

Worked this into dinner conversation last night and shared with my husband and son that my list is “coffee, bacon, butter, flour, and sugar.” My kid said “but what about pancakes?!” And my husband was like “oh don’t worry, she got that covered…” Close enough!

Jeanne

Jason Kottke linked to this post and it started its own response thread…small compared to CoJ but large for Kottke.org !

Kate

So many things, but if I had to pick one, it would be lemon oil! It adds flavour and depth to baking, salad dressings, and marinades. My secret weapon! My other four would be: coffee, grass-fed butter, eggs and prawns (not all in the same dish!)

gilli

Olive oil fresh baguette onions Everything bagel spice avocados

Maywyn

Black pepper, olive oil, cumin, garlic and chili powder

Annie

Coffee, olive oil, eggs, lemons, black pepper. You can always have breakfast.

Aerevyn

Olive oil greek yoghurt coffee parmesan cheese chicken thighs

Sophia

Penzey’s Fox Point seasoning (dips, soups, sauces, this makes everything savory better) Hummus Tomatoes (fresh and canned) Tumeric (a sprinkle will give anything a golden buttery color) Himalayan pink salt

Lucia

Coffee Eggs Nonfat Greek yogurt Rice Popcorn I love fruit but we buy a variety so I didn’t include it here. The stuff above I am fairly uncompromising about!

Lisa

Beechers cheese Grainy bread Coffee Good tomatoes Dark chocolate

Lauren

I recently discovered the Salsa Soleada from Siete and now need to keep several jars in my pantry at all times so I never run out – https://sietefoods.com/shop/seasonings-sauces-and-beans/salsa/salsa-soleada-4-jars/?srsltid=AfmBOoqdlPCIjmIIWBsglm8FuqjthtzeEpIPCtNjldy5eLzKEkOVza5p&size=10.5oz. It is great on its own and I mix it with a scoop of sour cream to make a dressing for my turkey taco salads – a regular meal in our house.

Leave a comment